Discover the Top 12 Best Restaurants in St Augustine’s Historic District: Indulge in Delicious Cuisine and Unforgettable Ambiance!

If you’re searching for the ultimate foodie destination, look no further than the charming town of St Augustine – renowned for being the oldest city in America. With cobblestoned streets and a vibrant atmosphere, St Augustine’s Historic District offers a plethora of small shops and, of course, restaurants. From fine dining to riverside pubs with scenic views, there’s no shortage of options when it comes to restaurants in St Augustine.

Seafood lovers, in particular, are in for a treat, thanks to the abundance of fresh catch from the oceanfront. Many restaurants in St Augustine also offer a Spanish-inspired menu, paying homage to the city’s founding by Spanish explorers in 1565. Don’t miss out on the culinary delights that make St Augustine a must-visit destination. 

Reservations at Restaurants in St Augustine’s Historic District

If you’re planning to dine out in St Augustine’s Historic District, it’s a good idea to make reservations in advance, especially if you’re traveling with a large party or visiting during peak seasons. Most restaurants in the area accept reservations, and many also offer call-ahead seating.

If you don’t have reservations, don’t worry. Many restaurants also have waiting lists where you can put your name down and explore the charming cobblestone streets of Downtown St Augustine while you wait for a table to become available.

Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner for two or a fun night out with friends and family, making reservations in advance can help ensure a smooth and enjoyable dining experience in St Augustine’s Historic District.

Looking for the ultimate dining experience during your visit to St Augustine’s Historic District? Don’t worry. We’ve got you covered! Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, fine dining, or waterfront views, we’ve compiled a list of 12 restaurants in St Augustine that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you wanting more. So, before you make any reservations or plans, be sure to check out our expertly curated list of the best restaurants in town. Trust us. You won’t want to miss out on these culinary delights!

1 – Enjoy Delicious Southern-Inspired Cuisine and Spectacular Views at River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge

Are you ready to indulge in mouth-watering cuisine and breathtaking views during your St Augustine getaway? Look no further than River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge. This hidden gem offers a stunning view of the Matanzas River and the historic Castillo de San Marcos Fort.

Get ready to savor southern-inspired cuisine featuring some of the best steaks and seafood in St Augustine. Every dish is prepared with care and features fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Make sure to visit the rooftop lounge for some of the best views of St Augustine while enjoying your delicious meal. Don’t forget to make a reservation in advance to secure your spot at this popular restaurant.

2 – Experience Old World Charm and Flavorful Dishes at Columbia House

Columbia House is one of St Augustine’s most iconic restaurants, serving up mouth-watering Cuban and Spanish dishes in a beautiful setting. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted with stunning hand-painted tiles, beautiful art, and a serene Spanish-style fountain. Whether you’re in the mood for their famous Queso Fundido, delectable Salmon “Aurora,” or the flavorful Picadillo “Criollo,” Columbia House has something to satisfy your cravings.

Make sure to dress to impress, as they do have a dress code, and we recommend making reservations to ensure you get a spot at this popular spot. Don’t miss out on the chance to experience old-world charm and flavorful dishes at Columbia House.

3 – Fresh and Flavorful Seafood at Catch 27 in St Augustine’s Historic District

Catch 27 is a must-visit restaurant in St Augustine for seafood lovers. The restaurant prides itself on serving only the freshest fish, shrimp, and clams, all caught daily from Florida’s pristine waters. But it’s not just the freshness that sets Catch 27 apart; their commitment to using seasonal ingredients and locally sourced produce ensures that every dish is bursting with flavor.

Named after Florida, the 27th state, this elegant restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Enjoy a meal in the cozy and inviting dining room or bask in the beautiful Florida weather on their lovely patio. Whether you’re in the mood for classic fish and chips, shrimp and grits, or something more adventurous, the menu at Catch 27 has something for everyone.

So, if you’re looking for a seafood feast in St Augustine, make sure to put Catch 27 on your list of must-visit restaurants.

4 – Fine Dining at Its Best: Experience the Exquisite Menu at Collage in St Augustine’s Historic District

For an unforgettable night of fine dining in St Augustine, look no further than Collage. This elegant restaurant offers an exquisite menu made from the freshest and highest quality ingredients, all prepared from scratch to perfection. From local seafood to steaks, lamb, and veal, every dish is a work of art that will delight your senses.

Collage’s elegant ambiance and impeccable service make it the perfect choice for a special occasion or a romantic evening out. And with its prime location in the heart of St Augustine’s Historic District, you can enjoy a leisurely stroll after your meal and take in the charming atmosphere of this historic city.

Reservations are highly recommended to dine at Collage, so be sure to book your table in advance to avoid disappointment. Treat yourself to a truly unforgettable dining experience at Collage in St Augustine’s Historic District.

5 – Step Back in Time at Prohibition Kitchen – A Retro-Chic Restaurant with Delicious Food and Live Music in St Augustine

Prohibition Kitchen is not just a restaurant, it’s an experience that will transport you back in time to the prohibition era. Step inside and soak up the retro-chic ambiance while enjoying delicious food that will leave your taste buds dancing. The restaurant is located right on St. George Street, making it a perfect spot for a fun night out.

Their menu offers a delightful range of gourmet pub grub, from delicious soups and salads to mouthwatering burgers, sandwiches, and more. Don’t miss out on their famous Handspun Milkshakes and Floats, which are a perfect way to end your meal.

But it’s not just about the food at Prohibition Kitchen. They have a great selection of cocktails that will take you on a journey back to the prohibition era. Plus, the live music will add to the overall experience and make for a memorable night out. So gather your friends and family, and head to Prohibition Kitchen for a night you won’t forget.

6 – The Floridian Restaurant: A Southern Comfort Haven

If you’re seeking authentic Florida dining, you’ll find no better place than The Floridian Restaurant. Craving Shrimp and Grits or a hearty Dixie burger? You’re in for a treat! The Floridian offers some of the best southern comfort food in Florida.

Every dish is made with fresh, seasonal ingredients, and the menu is updated regularly to keep things interesting. Whether you’re a meat lover or a vegan, The Floridian has something delicious for everyone. Try their refreshing salads for a lighter option that still packs a flavorful punch!

7- Experience the Taste of Ireland and Seafood at Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House

Enjoy Irish-inspired dishes and fresh seafood at this lively pub with river views. Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House is the perfect spot to indulge in delicious food while experiencing the traditional Irish pub atmosphere. This beloved St. Augustine restaurant serves up tasty Irish fare such as Shepherd’s Pie, Bangers & Mash, and Fish and Chips, all made with the freshest ingredients.

But that’s not all — Meehan’s also boasts an impressive oyster bar, offering a variety of fresh, local oysters. Sit back and relax in the garden-like back patio or the deck overlooking the river, while savoring your meal and soaking up the lively atmosphere.

The fun doesn’t stop there, as Meehan’s hosts many exciting events throughout the year. On select nights, you can also enjoy live music while dining, adding an extra element of fun to your evening. Whether you’re looking for a night out with friends, a romantic dinner for two, or a family gathering, Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House is a must-visit destination in St. Augustine

8 – Experience the Taste of Mexico in the Heart of Downtown St Augustine at Casa Maya

Step inside the charming and historic house-turned-restaurant and be welcomed by the vibrant colors and lively atmosphere. Casa Maya is not just a restaurant but a whole entertainment package, with live music performances every evening that will get you in the mood for a fiesta.

The menu boasts a mouthwatering selection of classic Mexican dishes, including their signature fresh seafood tacos that are a must-try. Whether you’re in the mood for fajitas, enchiladas, or a hearty burrito, Casa Maya has it all. And if you’re looking for something refreshing to drink, their margaritas are legendary.

As a popular spot for locals and tourists alike, Casa Maya operates on a first-come, first-served basis, so make sure to arrive early to snag a table. Don’t worry about the wait, though, as the vibrant atmosphere and lively music will keep you entertained until your table is ready. Get ready to indulge in the best Mexican food St Augustine has to offer at Casa Maya.

9 – One of the Top Seafood Restaurants in St Augustine: Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grill

If you’re searching for the perfect seafood spot with a historical ambiance, you can’t go wrong with Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grill, one of the top restaurants in St Augustine. With its prime location right on the water, Harry’s serves up authentic New Orleans-style seafood with Southern, Cajun, and Creole flavors. Their extensive menu also features modern dishes to please every palate.

Established in 1987, Harry’s occupies a charming historic building that overlooks the Matanzas River. The restaurant boasts a stunning indoor dining area decorated with antique fixtures, artwork, and memorabilia that tell the story of the city’s rich history. If you prefer dining al fresco, Harry’s offers a beautifully lit courtyard and patio area where you can savor your meal while enjoying the fresh Florida air.

Whether you’re looking for a romantic evening out or a casual gathering with friends, Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grill is the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings for delicious seafood and a one-of-a-kind dining experience.

10 – Michael’s St Augustine: A Charming Spanish-style Restaurant with Seasonal Menus

Looking for a charming and delightful dining experience? Head to Michael’s St Augustine! This unique restaurant is nestled in historic St Augustine and boasts a Spanish-style menu that guests will absolutely love. Housed in a historic building dating back to 1764, Michael’s offers an indoor dining room and an outdoor patio area that comes alive at night, creating the perfect ambiance for a romantic evening.

What sets Michael’s St Augustine apart is its commitment to using fresh, local ingredients in its Coastal Spanish Inspired Cuisine. The menu is changed seasonally, so you can always expect to try something new and exciting. Michael’s is also a member of the Independent Restaurant Association, which is known for its dedication to maintaining the highest culinary standards. You can be sure that every dish at Michael’s is created with the utmost care and attention to detail.

Whether you are looking for a romantic dinner for two or a night out with friends, Michael’s St Augustine is the perfect choice. Come and experience the charm and elegance of one of the best restaurants in St Augustine!

11 – Café Alcazar – A Unique Fine-Dining Experience in St. Augustine

In the heart of St. Augustine, Café Alcazar is a truly unique restaurant located within the historic Lightner Museum. Once an indoor swimming pool in the Alcazar Hotel, the restaurant now serves lunch daily to museum visitors and locals alike.

Café Alcazar’s menu features unique dishes crafted from fresh, local, and organic ingredients. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and creativity shines through in every bite. From savory soups to delicious salads, and entrees like shrimp and grits, Café Alcazar has something for everyone.

While reservations are not required, they are highly recommended for this one-of-a-kind dining experience. After your meal, take a stroll through the Lightner Museum to see historic pieces from the American Gilded Age.

Café Alcazar is just one of the many fantastic restaurants in St Augustine that combine historic charm with exceptional cuisine. Whether you’re a local or visiting for the first time, a meal at Café Alcazar is a must-try experience.

12 – Experience Delicious Fusion Cuisine and Stunning Views at Casa Reina in St Augustine

Casa Reina is one of the most exciting and newest restaurants in St. Augustine, and it’s already making a name for itself with its unique blend of Mexican and Latin American cuisine combined with Florida’s coastal flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for some mouthwatering street tacos, crispy chimichangas, Nashville-style chicken tacos, or some succulent honey-lime glazed salmon, Casa Reina has got you covered. And don’t forget to save some room for their impressive desserts, including the classic churros and Tres Leches.

But what really sets Casa Reina apart is the breathtaking view from their rooftop. Sit back, relax, and enjoy stunning vistas of the river and the iconic Bridge of Lions while you savor your meal. It’s the perfect spot to take in the sights and sounds of St. Augustine while indulging in some delicious food.

Don’t miss out on this gem of a restaurant located in the heart of St. Augustine. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Casa Reina is a must-visit spot among the top restaurants in St. Augustine. So come on in, and let Casa Reina tantalize your taste buds and treat you to some unforgettable views.

---

St Augustine’s Historic District boasts many fantastic restaurants catering to different dining preferences. Whether you’re a seafood lover or a fan of Spanish cuisine, there’s a restaurant that will meet your needs. From upscale dining to casual brunch spots, there’s no shortage of fantastic dining options to explore.

So, have you had the chance to try any of the amazing restaurants in St. Augustine yet? We would love to hear about your favorite dining experience in the comments below. Share your recommendations and help others discover the best restaurants in St Augustine!

Dear MouseEars TV readers, This post may contain affiliate links. If you click on one of these links and make a purchase, we will earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Featured photo: LuckyBusiness via Canva.com